When The Perfect Candidate is Not Out There, Who Do You Hire?

So, you’re on the hunt for your unicorn—the perfect candidate who ticks all the boxes. But what if that magical person just isn’t out there? You might need to rethink your strategy in today’s competitive labor market. Should you focus on fit, culture, experience, or potential? Let’s dive into it!

Hiring For Profit

Picture this: you find someone who gets you. They think, work like you, and fit right into your company’s vibe. Sounds perfect, right? But there’s more to consider.

Pros:

  • Less turnover: People who feel they fit are most likely to stick around.
  • More engagement: Employees who fit well are generally happier and more engaged.
  • Stability and growth: A good fit can drive company stability and promote growth since everyone’s rowing in the same direction.

Cons:

  • Stifles innovation: Hiring people who think just like you can limit fresh, innovative ideas.
  • Creates a “yes-man” culture: No healthy conflict exists and diverse perspectives.
  • Overlooks diverse talent: You might miss out on great candidates who don’t perfectly “fit” but could bring valuable perspectives, experience, and skills.

Hiring For Culture

Now, let’s talk culture. You want someone who shares your values and work style. It’s like finding a new member who clicks with everyone.

Pros:

  • Positive employees: Employees feel more fulfilled and motivated when values align.
  • Long-term success: Cultural compatibility can lead to long-term career satisfaction and success.
  • Peace of mind: Knowing they fit the culture, you’ll feel more confident in your hiring decisions.

Cons:

  • Lack of diverse ideas: Similar to hiring for fit, focusing solely on culture can limit the range of perspectives.
  • Risk of similarity: Too much emphasis on culture can create a bias where everyone thinks alike, which can be detrimental to innovation.

Hiring For Experience

What about experience? You want someone who’s been there, done that, and can hit the ground running. Sounds efficient, right? Not always.

Pros:

  • Faster onboarding: Experienced candidates require less time to get up to speed.
  • Immediate expertise: They bring valuable skills and knowledge from day one.

Cons:

  • Learning curve still exists: Every company has its processes and culture, so there’s always something new to learn.
  • Limits your talent pool: Focusing only on experience can shrink the number of viable candidates.
  • Potential culture clashes: Experienced hires might struggle to adapt to your unique company culture, leading to friction.

Hiring For Potential

Finally, let’s consider potential. You’re looking for someone with the skills to grow and thrive, even if they’re not the perfect fit right now.

Pros:

  • Larger talent pool: You open yourself up to a broader range of candidates.
  • Encourages development and loyalty: Investing in your employees’ growth can foster loyalty and commitment.
  • Adds flexibility and creativity: Employees hired for potential can bring fresh perspectives and adapt easily to new challenges.

Cons:

  • Requires time and investment: Developing potential takes time, resources, and patience.
  • Steep learning curves: It might take longer for these hires to become fully productive.
  • No guarantees: Despite your investment, there’s always a risk they might not stay long-term or meet expectations.

The Balanced Approach

So, who do you hire? There’s no one-size-fits-all answer. Think about what works best for your business and the role you’re hiring for. Ask yourself:

  • What’s negotiable? What skills or traits can you be flexible about?
  • What’s non-negotiable? What are the absolute must-haves for this role?
  • Who can shine with the support you offer? Consider the support and development opportunities you can provide to help your new hire succeed.

Answer these questions, and you’ll be on your way to finding the right person, even if they aren’t a perfect unicorn.

Conclusion

Balancing fit, culture, experience, and potential is key. Each approach has its upsides and downsides, so consider what your company really needs.

Want to chat more about this or recruitment and hiring topics? Reach out to me at tracy@essencerecruitment.ca. I’d love to hear from you!

Tracy Arno, CEO/Founder
Essence Recruitment

Recent Blog Posts

The Reskilling Revolution: Are You Ready for the Future of Work?

The world of work is changing fast! Did you know that by 2030, a billion people will need new skills tokeep up? This is why there's a big push for reskilling and upskilling –learning new things or improvingexisting skills to stay relevant. What is the difference...

Are Your Employees Thriving?

Have you noticed a change in your employee's behavior? Has there been a shift in your company culture? Does it seem that productivity is down, and no matter what you do, employees want more and more? You are not alone. According to Gallup, 51% of currently employed...

The Impact of AI – Are we taking the Human out of Recruitment?

AI is currently at the forefront of discussions in recruitment, as it is in various other fields. I continue to seek to understand AI and its implications for the recruitment industry, trying to keep up with the continuing advancement of technology. Applicant tracking...

The Rules of the Resumes – Trends for 2024

It’s a New Year. Are you ready for a new career? If the answer is yes, then you need to start with your resume. The look and feel of a resume have changed significantly in the past five years. Our world has turned digital, and so has your resume. The creativity,...

From Hire to High Performer – Effective Onboarding

Welcome to the world of onboarding, the final but one of the most important steps of the recruitment process. W. My advice DON’T rush through this step and DON’T assume your new hire is “good to go” until you’ve ensured their onboarding experience has been...

“The Offer” – Put your best foot forward!

Congratulations, you found the perfect candidate for the job! But wait – you haven’t sealed the deal just yet. Presenting a winning offer is an important part of the recruitment process. The discussion goes beyond just offering a salary—it's about conveying your...

Decoding the Dance: Mastering the Art of the Interview Process

Ah, the interview process. It’s a time-honored tradition of handshakes, sweaty palms, and an in-depth assessment of job candidates' skills, abilities, and potential within your company. Let’s start with a few facts: A thorough interview process is essential....

The Recruitment Process – Before During and After

Recruitment should be as simple as posting a job and finding a candidate. Wrong. You might be surprised to learn that the recruitment process involves several stages, both BEFORE and AFTER the main process of sourcing and interviewing candidates. Finding and...